One of the key things the Reds wanted to change from previous teams is to hone in on good defense. Willy Taveras, Jay Bruce, Chris Dickerson, Alex Gonzalez and Ramon Hernandez are all guys who were not on the team last April and for the most part, last season (Gonzo was, but he wasn’t playing). Thats a big change on the defensive side of things and to be fair, the Reds were not very good defenders last year as they were among the bottom of the league in defensive efficiency ratio (the rate in which balls in play – non HR’s – were turned into outs).
This year the Reds have seen some defensive issues come about with errors from time to time, but if you are reading this you are more than likely of the thinking that errors don’t tell you how good or bad a defense actually is. But I thought it would be a good time to take a look at how both the individuals and the team have performed to this point.
The Reds as a team are currently sporting a defensive efficiency ratio of .714, meaning they are turning balls in play into outs at a 71.4% rate, which ranks 4th best in all of baseball. Now I would like to stress that we are working with a small sample size here and things can change quickly, but so far things are looking good on the team scale.
As far as the individual scale goes, I have always been a fan of the system that Justin developed and I have used it in the past as well. Its pretty simple, but more often than not, it jives pretty well with scouting reports and other defensive systems. All data is gathered from TheHardballTimes.com. Again, lets really stress small sample size here, as for individual players you typically want more than one seasons worth of data and we are working with one month worth of data here.
First Base – Joey Votto
Votto currently ranks 17th out 0f 28 qualified first baseman, less than 1 play below average. The thing here is that Votto is working with less than 30 plays like most other first baseman, so the sample is extemely small.
Second Base – Brandon Phillips
Phillips ranks 2nd out of the qualified second baseman at +5 plays on the season, trailing just Howie Kendrick. Small sample of course, but Phillips is widely acknowledged as one of the best glove men in baseball.
Shortstop – Alex Gonzalez
Gonzalez currently ranks 18th out of 27 qualified shortstops with -1.3 plays. There have been moments where Gonzalez has looked quite good and other times he has looked like Jeff Keppinger. My eyes tell me that he isn’t a positive defender anymore though.
Third Base – Edwin Encarnacion
Encarnacion is 22nd out of 27 qualified third baseman. I don’t think I need to say much here, nothing has changed with him in years.
Left Field – Chris Dickerson/Jerry Hairston
The combo of Dickerson and Hairston currently rank 5th in baseball at +3.25 plays in left field. That certainly is a step up over last season.
Center Field – Willy Taveras
Willy Taveras is currently 22nd out of 28 qualified center fielders at -3.2 plays. Its pretty early though, as Nate McLouth is a positive defender right now after being the worst in baseball last year. Willy has looked fine to me.
Right Field – Jay Bruce
Bruce ranks out at -2.6 plays this season early on. My eyes don’t see that one, but we will see. Jay, like Joey Votto, is working with such a small number of plays right now (32) that one play made or not made can really make a big swing in this.
Overall
The defense certainly looks improved at this point in the season and the only two positions I am worried about are 3B and SS. It will be interesting to see how Adam Rosales does over there with Edwin on the disabled list.